Turkey-Israel Relations: Could Military Conflict Erupt?

PoliticsCould Turkey and Israel go to war?

TL;DR

Turkey and Israel's relationship has sharply deteriorated amid the Gaza war and regional power competition, with escalating rhetoric raising risks of miscalculation despite an outright military conflict remaining unlikely.

Key Takeaways

1Turkey-Israel relations collapsed following the October 7th attacks and Gaza war, with Turkey cutting trade ties and accusing Israel of genocide while Israel labeled Erdogan an antisemitic dictator.
2Both nations compete for regional hegemony in the post-American Middle East, particularly in Syria where they pursue opposing strategic objectives after Assad's 2024 collapse.
3Israel has allied with Greece and Cyprus for Mediterranean energy and defense cooperation, while Turkey counters by strengthening ties with Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt.
4Escalated rhetoric serves domestic political purposes for both leaders: Israeli politicians need security threats ahead of elections, while Erdogan seeks to boost Turkey's standing with the Arab world.
5Direct military conflict remains unlikely due to shared US alliance, NATO ties, and diplomatic channels, though heightened tensions increase risks of miscalculation and unintended consequences.

Notable Quotes

“Needs a threat to run against, hence his blunt labeling of Turkey as the new Iran.”
— Bobby Ghosh (Foreign Policy)

“Netanyahu sees war, or the perpetual threat of war as central to his political survival.”
— Analysis in video

“I like him, describing him as a very good friend and a great leader.”
— Trump (on Erdogan)

Chapters

1. Historical Context: From Recognition to Deterioration

Turkey was the first Muslim-majority country to recognize Israel in 1949. Relations experienced decades of fluctuation, hitting lows after the 2008-2009 Gaza war and the 2010 Turkish aid flotilla raid, before rebounding in 2022 with restored diplomatic ties and Mediterranean energy projects.

2. The Gaza War Collapse

Relations collapsed following October 7th attacks. Turkey cut trade ties, accused Israel of genocide, backed South Africa's ICJ case, and labeled Hamas as freedom fighters. Netanyahu responded by calling Erdogan an antisemitic dictator.

3. Regional Power Competition

Both nations seek to fill the vacuum left by weakened Iran and a reduced US role. Syria became the key battleground—Turkey allied with new leader Ahmed al-Shar for reconstruction influence, while Israel took control of southern Syrian territory and launched strikes at government infrastructure.

4. Alliance Building and Strategic Partnerships

Israel allied with Greece and Cyprus for Mediterranean energy and defense cooperation. Turkey countered by strengthening ties with Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt, and backed infrastructure initiatives like a Turkey-Saudi railway through Syria and Jordan.

5. Rhetoric and Domestic Politics

Both leaders use inflammatory rhetoric for domestic gain. Israeli politicians frame Turkey as a threat to boost security credentials ahead of elections. Erdogan escalates anti-Israel messaging to position Turkey as protector of Arab interests and exploit perceived US-Israel tensions.

6. Risk of Conflict vs. Likelihood

While military confrontation appears unlikely due to shared US alliance, NATO ties, and Azerbaijan diplomatic channels, heightened rhetoric and geopolitical competition increase risks of miscalculation and unintended consequences. Trump stated he doesn't expect conflict during his presidency.

Key People & Entities

Recep Tayyip Erdogan: Turkish President; critic of Israel, cut trade ties and accused Israel of genocide
Benjamin Netanyahu: Israeli Prime Minister; labeled Erdogan antisemitic dictator, building hexagon alliance
Naftali Bennett: Former Israeli PM running for election; labeled Turkey 'the new Iran'
Ahmed al-Shar: New Syrian government leader; close ally of Turkey
Bashar al-Assad: Former Syrian regime leader whose collapse in late 2024 became pivot point for regional competition
Donald Trump: US President; stated mutual respect for Erdogan and skepticism of Turkey-Israel conflict

Glossary

Regional hegemon: A nation that seeks dominance and leadership within its geographic region's political and military affairs
Post-American Middle East: A geopolitical scenario where the United States reduces its military and political involvement in Middle Eastern affairs
ICJ: International Court of Justice, the principal judicial organ of the United Nations
Miscalculation: An unintended military or diplomatic error that could trigger escalation or conflict between nations

Explore