The Taiwan-China Question: Two Nations, One Name

PoliticsCan there ever really be “one China?”

TL;DR

Taiwan's identity evolved from identifying as the Republic of China to asserting a distinct Taiwanese identity, creating an ongoing geopolitical tension with the People's Republic of China's insistence on the 'one China' principle.

Key Takeaways

1Taiwan's passport didn't mention 'Taiwan' until 2003, reflecting its historical identification as the Republic of China rather than a separate entity
2The split originated from the 1949 Chinese Civil War when the Communist Party took mainland China and Nationalist forces retreated to Taiwan
3Taiwan's democratization in the 1990s catalyzed the emergence of a distinct Taiwanese identity separate from the ROC's claim to represent all of China
4The US shifted diplomatic recognition from the ROC to the PRC in 1979, adopting the 'one China' policy, but maintains economic and military ties with Taiwan
5Taiwan's semiconductor industry (TSMC produces over 90% of global chips) makes it economically critical to both the US and global supply chains
6The majority of Taiwanese prefer the current ambiguous status quo over either independence or unification to avoid conflict

Notable Quotes

“From 1949, 1950 onward, you have two separate jurisdictions. They both claim legitimacy. So they all both claim that they are representative of China.”
— Analyst

“The government of the United States of America acknowledges the Chinese position that there is but one China and Taiwan is part of China.”
— US Official Statement

“The PRC is not a democracy. There's no signs that it's going to become a democracy anytime soon. The idea of an independent Taiwan is still anathema to the CCP in Beijing and uh is probably a cause for war.”
— Analyst

“The majority of people in Taiwan just want the status quo. they are willing to live with this sort of um very vague international status that they have because they don't essentially don't want war.”
— Analyst

Chapters

1. Taiwan's Identity Before 2003

Taiwan's early passports identified the island as the Republic of China with no mention of Taiwan itself, reflecting the post-1949 division after the Chinese Civil War when Nationalists retreated to the island.

2. The Cold War Shift

In 1971, the US pivoted toward the PRC to counter Soviet influence, resulting in the ROC losing its UN seat and the US formally recognizing the PRC as the sole government of China in 1979.

3. Taiwan's Democratization and Identity Emergence

Taiwan's transition from martial law (1949-1987) to full democracy in the 1990s enabled the emergence of a distinct Taiwanese identity, exemplified by President Lee Teng-hui's 1995 Cornell University speech.

4. The Passport as a Symbol

In 2002-2003, Taiwan added 'Taiwan' to its passport cover, reflecting the majority population's shift toward identifying as Taiwanese rather than Chinese, which Beijing viewed as a violation of the one China principle.

5. Beijing's Escalating Pressure

As the PRC became the world's second-largest economy, it intensified pressure on other nations through economic leverage and weaponry (such as 1995-96 missile exercises) to reinforce the one China principle and isolate Taiwan.

6. The Geopolitical Triangle

The US maintains a balancing act: recognizing the PRC diplomatically while remaining Taiwan's largest weapons supplier and relying on Taiwan's TSMC for semiconductor production, crucial to both nations.

7. The Current Stalemate

Most Taiwanese prefer the ambiguous status quo over independence or unification to avoid conflict, while the PRC views independence as cause for war and the US remains reluctant to formally recognize Taiwan as a sovereign state.

Key People & Entities

Chiang Kai-Shek: Leader of the Chinese Nationalist Party and first president of the ROC; led forces that retreated to Taiwan in 1949
Mao Zedong: Founder and leader of the PRC until his death in 1976; his death enabled the PRC to move closer to the US
Deng Xiaoping: PRC leader who came to power after Mao's death and helped facilitate closer US-China relations
Henry Kissinger: US National Security Adviser who secretly visited China in 1971, initiating the US pivot toward the PRC
President Richard Nixon: First US president to publicly visit communist China after two decades of diplomatic isolation, following Kissinger's secret visit
Lee Teng-hui: President of Taiwan; his 1995 Cornell University speech marked a pivotal moment in asserting Taiwan's distinct identity
Chen Shui-bian: First Democratic Progressive Party president of Taiwan; pushed legislation in 2002 to add the word 'Taiwan' to passports
President Xi Jinping: Current leader of the PRC who emphasizes the Taiwan question as the most important issue in China-US relations

Glossary

One China Principle: The diplomatic position that there is only one sovereign Chinese state; the PRC claims it represents all of China including Taiwan, while the ROC historically claimed to represent the mainland.
ROC (Republic of China): The government established by Chinese Nationalists that retreated to Taiwan in 1949 after losing the Chinese Civil War; still the official name of Taiwan's government.
PRC (People's Republic of China): The communist government established on mainland China in 1949 after the Chinese Communist Party's victory in the civil war.
UN Resolution 2758: The 1971 UN resolution that recognized the PRC as the sole legitimate representative of China, displacing the ROC from its UN seat.
TSMC: Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, which produced over 90% of the world's semiconductor chips as of 2024, making Taiwan economically critical to global supply chains.

Explore