America's Two Founding Stories and the Battle Over National Identity

PoliticsThe fight over America’s national story | The Gray Area

TL;DR

Constitutional law professor Kermit Roosevelt III argues that America has two incompatible founding narratives—the 1776 founding based on exclusive individualism and the Reconstruction founding based on inclusive equality—and understanding this conflict is key to resolving contemporary political divisions.

Key Takeaways

1America has two distinct foundings: 1776 created a collection of states with no unified values, while Reconstruction (1863-1868) created a unified nation dedicated to anti-slavery, equality, and birthright citizenship.
2The values Americans associate with 1776—equality and anti-slavery—were actually introduced by Reconstruction abolitionists and the 14th Amendment, not the original founding documents.
3American history cycles between periods of Reconstruction (pushing inclusive, egalitarian values) and Redemption (backlash toward exclusive individualism), with long-term progress despite short-term oscillation.
4The national narrative we tell ourselves profoundly shapes political identity and behavior; choosing different heroes like Frederick Douglass and Thaddeus Stevens over Thomas Jefferson could reshape American identity.
5Accepting failure as part of America's story—particularly the failure of the original Constitution to prevent the Civil War—enables maturation and learning rather than defensive mythology.
6Constitutional reform and structural changes to make government more democratic are necessary to reduce polarization and move the country toward reconstruction values.
7National identity matters for mobilizing citizens and maintaining social cohesion, but requires balancing historical accuracy with inspirational narrative.

Notable Quotes

“We will always be refining and improving our idea of what it means to be American. That's healthy. That's the process of civic maturation. What's problematic is when you have two stories that are really opposed and incompatible, and those stories are kind of fighting it out again and again.”
— Kermit Roosevelt III

“The Constitution did not end slavery. The South ended slavery basically because they massively overplayed their hand and seceded.”
— Kermit Roosevelt III

“If you raise your kids so that they never fail, there's going to be a moment where they encounter failure for the first time and it's devastating. But if you teach them mistakes are how you learn, then they go on and function independently.”
— Kermit Roosevelt III

“I consider myself a patriot. I love America. I believe that our people are better than our government. Our constitution and our political system are dysfunctional and anti-democratic in a bunch of ways.”
— Kermit Roosevelt III

Chapters

1. Introduction: The Two Stories of America

Host Jon Hill introduces constitutional law professor Kermit Roosevelt III and the central tension in American identity: the conflicting narratives of 1776 and Reconstruction that continue to shape contemporary politics.

2. The First Founding: 1776 and the Collection of States

Roosevelt explains that 1776 created a confederation of states, not a unified nation. The Constitution used the plural 'United States' and states retained sovereignty. Crucially, the founding was not anti-slavery or dedicated to equality—all states were slave states.

3. The Second Founding: Reconstruction and Revolutionary Change

Reconstruction (1863-1868) represented as dramatic a break as the original founding. The 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments abolished slavery, created birthright citizenship, and established equality rights. Congress remade Southern state governments to ratify these amendments, fundamentally restructuring the nation.

4. Exclusive Individualism vs. Inclusive Equality

Roosevelt outlines two competing ideologies: the founding's exclusive individualism (defining America by who is excluded, skeptical of redistribution) versus Reconstruction's inclusive equality (birthright citizenship, redistribution to remedy slavery, focus on national unity over state autonomy).

5. Reinterpreting the Declaration: From Document to Symbol

The Declaration's famous phrase 'all men are created equal' was not originally understood as anti-slavery. Abolitionists reinterpreted it to argue slavery contradicted American principles. Even Confederates cited the Declaration, claiming continuity with 1776 by asserting independence from federal overreach.

6. Why National Stories Matter

Narratives give meaning and identity to a people. For America, national identity is ideological rather than racial or religious, making the story we tell ourselves crucial for cohesion, sacrifice, and determining who are heroes versus villains.

7. The Cycle of Reconstruction and Redemption

American history oscillates: Reconstruction advances equality (1865-1877), Redemption restores white supremacy (1877-1950s), Second Reconstruction via civil rights (1950s-1970s), Second Redemption returns to founding values (1980-present). Long-term progress is visible over centuries despite short-term cycles.

8. Constitutional Failure and American Maturity

The Civil War represented catastrophic failure of the founders' Constitution, not a challenge it overcame. Accepting that the original system failed—rather than claiming it contained 'seeds' of abolition—enables honest assessment and mature political thinking, like parenting that allows children to learn from mistakes.

9. Reframing American Heroes and Monuments

Rather than tearing down Jefferson and Washington memorials, Roosevelt suggests shifting identification to Reconstruction heroes like Frederick Douglass, Harriet Tubman, Charles Sumner, and Thaddeus Stevens, allowing Americans to embrace an identity free from cognitive dissonance about slaveholding founders.

10. Toward a Third Reconstruction

Roosevelt calls for deliberate political choice toward Reconstruction values rather than passive oscillation. This requires structural constitutional reform to make government more democratic, reduce polarization, and enable a progressive era of functional improvement aligned with inclusive egalitarian ideals.

Key People & Entities

Kermit Roosevelt III: Constitutional law professor at the University of Pennsylvania and author of 'The Nation That Never Was: Reconstructing America's Story'
Thomas Jefferson: Author of the Declaration of Independence; slaveholder whose legacy illustrates the tension between founding ideals and founding practices
Abraham Lincoln: President who invoked 1776 as a unifying moment; helped establish the 'founding fathers' concept; committed to preserving the Union during the Civil War
Thaddeus Stevens: Radical Republican member of Reconstruction Congress; advocated for land redistribution and Black equality; proposed as an alternative hero to founding fathers
Charles Sumner: Senator and Reconstruction Congress member; advocate for Black rights and equality; example of Reconstruction era hero alternative to founders
Frederick Douglass: Formerly enslaved abolitionist who reinterpreted the Declaration of Independence to argue against slavery; proposed as alternative American hero representing reconstruction values
Harriet Tubman: Formerly enslaved abolitionist and Underground Railroad conductor; proposed as reconstruction-era American hero alternative to slaveholding founders
Malcolm X: Activist who understood the Declaration of Independence as providing remedies against government oppression; cited by Roosevelt as correctly applying founding logic

Glossary

Reconstruction: The period (1863-1868) following the Civil War when the federal government restructured Southern states, abolished slavery via the 13th Amendment, established birthright citizenship through the 14th Amendment, and prohibited race discrimination in voting through the 15th Amendment.
Redemption: Historical term for the period (1877-1950s) when white Southerners regained political control after Reconstruction ended, violently overthrowing racially integrated governments and re-establishing white supremacy through Jim Crow laws and disfranchisement.
Birthright citizenship: The constitutional principle established by the 14th Amendment that anyone born in the United States becomes a citizen regardless of race, ethnicity, or parental status, preventing the creation of permanent hereditary outsider classes.
Exclusive individualism: Roosevelt's term for the founding ideology emphasizing individual liberty, skepticism of redistribution, and definition of the political community by excluding outsiders (non-whites, non-landowners).
Inclusive equality: Roosevelt's term for Reconstruction ideology emphasizing national unity, equality rights across racial lines, birthright citizenship, and willingness to use redistribution to remedy historical injustices.
Originalism: A constitutional interpretation philosophy claiming to apply the original meaning of the Constitution; critics note originalists typically reference 1787 rather than 1868 (the 14th Amendment), selectively choosing which founding to privilege.
The Dred Scott decision: An 1857 Supreme Court ruling declaring that Black people descended from enslaved people could never be U.S. citizens and that racial boundaries around citizenship were matters of law, effectively denying Black people legal personhood.
Freedman's Bureau Act: Reconstruction legislation establishing the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands to provide education, economic support, and legal protection to formerly enslaved people, representing Reconstruction's commitment to equality through redistribution.
Second Reconstruction: Historians' term for the civil rights movement era (roughly 1950s-1970s), when federal intervention again advanced voting rights, desegregation, and racial equality, parallel to the original Reconstruction period.
Compromise of 1877: The political agreement ending Reconstruction by withdrawing federal troops from the South in exchange for Republican Rutherford B. Hayes's election as president, enabling white Southerners to regain control and begin Redemption.

Explore